How to Make a Good College List (With 3 Examples)

The first step to applying to colleges and universities is coming up with a list. Without a balanced college list, it’s not unlikely for you to feel disappointed due to the absence of any acceptance letters in the mail.

Creating a college list requires choosing institutions based on various factors. They include the student’s academic profile and personal preferences, and the school’s admissions history. To make a solid college list, it should have a good balance of reach schools, match schools and safety schools.

Refrain from assuming that a college list packed with 20 randomly selected schools is a good one.

There is a proper way to come up with something that can help increase your chances of gaining admission into at least one college or university of your liking. Continue reading if you are about to create a college list anytime soon and you want to make sure that it’s both balanced and realistic.

college list

13 Factors To Consider When Choosing A College

Factors to consider when creating a college list come aplenty. Some of them are the location, cost, programs, selectivity level and even weather. College-selection factors are subjective. This means that some may be more important for some students, while others may be less important for the rest.

So many things can make choosing institutions to apply to stressful and fatiguing. Leading the list is creating a list — without one, the process of choosing a college can become more unnerving.

Writing down random colleges and universities or those that your best buds plan to apply to is a complete no-no. That’s because selecting a college is a highly personal matter. After all, you will be the one who will work on a degree for the next few years of your life, and it’s your earned degree that will influence what you will do for the rest of your life.

It’s due to this why you should come up with a college list that meets your every need and preference.

Because different college-bound high schoolers have different requirements, factors to take into account when making a college list can vary greatly. The following, however, are some of the most important:

Tuition and Financial Aid

Almost 20% of students admitted to their dream colleges enrolled elsewhere due to the steep sticker price. It goes without saying that the cost is critical when it comes to deciding which schools should make it on your list.

Unless you have a substantial college fund or are guaranteed to win a full-ride scholarship, see to it that every institution you will put on your list won’t wreak havoc on the budget.

Don’t forget to look into financial aid — find out what kinds of aid are available, what percentage of freshmen students receive them, and how much each awardee gets.

College Location

Before shortlisting a college, determine whether you find being miles away from your loved ones an opportunity to become independent or something that can make you feel miserable and homesick every waking hour.

The answer will help you come up with a college list consisting of schools located in the right places.

The location is also a cost-related factor. This is most especially true if you plan to go to a public institution where cheaper in-state tuition and steeper out-of-state tuition are a thing. But if it’s a private college or university you wish to go to, there is no need to worry about this matter as the tuition cost is the same no matter where a student is from.

Institution Type

Another thing that can have a considerable impact on how much money you will have to spend to get your hands on a degree is the type of institution you wish to attend: private or public.

Everyone knows that private colleges and universities cost way more than public ones — sometimes up to 10 times more. Your chances of gaining admission into a public institution are higher, too, since some of the most selective schools are private. Don’t stop reading now because we will discuss acceptance rates in a few.

Campus Setting

Urban, suburban, town, rural — there are a handful of campus settings to choose from. It’s important to pick one where you will thrive so much better for the next four years.

Let’s check out the primary characteristics of these four campus settings to help you choose wisely:

  • Urban. Earning a degree from a school situated in the city is for you if you love being in an environment bustling with activity. It’s the perfect setting for you if you like diversity, which we will talk about in a few.
  • Suburban. As the name suggests, a suburban campus setting is perfect for those who wish to have some peace and quiet but still want easy access to the hustle and bustle of a busy city.
  • Town. Going to a school situated in a town is ideal for you if being a part of a small and cozy community is a plus. What’s more, plenty of college towns have pocket-friendly tuition costs.
  • Rural. Are you a nature lover? Then there is no doubt that a school with a rural campus setting is right for you. Many rural colleges rank high, too, such as Williams College, Bowdoin College and Hamilton College.

Admissions Test Policy

Thousands of US colleges and universities these days have a test-optional policy, which means that applicants are not obligated to submit their standardized test scores. It’s a wonderful idea to apply to any of them if you are unhappy with your test score or weren’t able to take the SAT or ACT.

Do you have a high test score and feel that it can convince the admissions officers that you are what they are looking for? Then go ahead and submit it — it might help increase your admissions chances.

For instance, 69% of applicants to Harvard submit their SAT scores despite the fact that the Ivy League is test-optional.

Related Article: Getting Into College With High GPA But Low SAT/ACT

Housing Cost

Especially if you plan to attend a college that’s miles away from home, you will have to decide between living on-campus and living off-campus. Each option comes with its own set of pros and cons, which you should weigh carefully.

Living on-campus allows you to enjoy the full college experience. It’s also usually cheaper than living off-campus despite having all sorts of amenities, plus it’s generally safer since one of a school’s priorities is the safety of its students.

However, on-campus living can limit your privacy. You may also wind up with a horrible roommate!

On the other hand, off-campus living gives you more freedom and privacy. Alas, it can be a costlier option. This is especially true if you have the apartment to yourself and it’s far from the campus.

Acceptance Rate

There is a quick way to know whether or not an institution should be included on your college list: check out the acceptance rate. The higher the number you see, the better your admissions chances.

But a low acceptance rate should be the least of your worries if your academic profile is so much better than the school’s admissions statistics, which you can access by checking out its Common Data Set (CDS).

Not too happy with your GPA, test score, admissions essay, and extracurriculars? Then focus on schools with the highest acceptance rates.

Academic Programs

Some colleges and universities are known for their top-notch STEM programs. On the other hand, some are revered for their world-class business programs.

Anywhere from 20% to 50% of freshmen students enter college not knowing what to pursue. If you are not one of them, it’s a great idea to come up with a college list centering on the program of your liking.

Still on the fence?

No worries — just make sure that you shortlist schools with plenty of options within the field you are interested in.

Racial And Ethnic Diversity

No matter if you are a part of an underrepresented group or you just want to have a better understanding of yourself and others, then consider choosing colleges that emphasize diversity.

Attending an institution where the student body consists of people from different races, ethnicities, cultures and religions comes with an assortment of perks.

For instance, it allows you to enjoy a richer educational experience as well as better communication and thought-processing skills. It also prepares you to thrive in a complex workforce.

Related Article: Most and Least Racially Diverse US Colleges and Universities


Just because you will be working on a degree doesn’t mean you will be spending the next four years of your life reading textbooks and acing exams. It’s due to this why filling your college list with schools offering a wide variety of extracurricular activities available for their students to partake in is a wonderful idea.

Having extracurriculars lets you learn skills and create a network, both of which will be valuable after graduation.

The more extracurricular activities are around, the greater your chances of finding one or two or more that can help you become a well-rounded college student and a promising employee in the near future.

Related Article: Is Volunteering an Extracurricular Activity?

School Size

College is so much bigger than high school, both figuratively and literally speaking. If you are from a small high school, even a small college may leave you dazed.

The size of a school is a factor in the college selection process that’s both vital and complex.

For instance, it’s true that a large campus may offer more amenities. However, you may have to take a bus or a train to get to your other classes.

On the other hand, a small campus may be cozy alright. But chances are there are fewer amenities and things to do, too. Avoiding people may prove to be challenging as well.


When it comes to well-known or high-ranking colleges and universities, accreditation is almost always a given. This means that you can forget about checking whether or not they are accredited, thus allowing you to save a great deal of time creating a balanced and well-thought-out college list.

However, it’s a completely different story when it comes to smaller institutions that not everyone talks about all the time. The same is true for online schools, no matter if operating purely on the internet or offering hybrid classes.

Checking that the school you are about to include on your college list is accredited allows you to enjoy quality education and qualify for financial aid. It also enables the credits you will earn from it to transfer to another accredited school, should you decide to switch colleges. More importantly, it will let you earn a degree employers respect.


Not too many students know the fact that the weather is an important factor in the college selection process.

Studies show that the weather can impact a student’s mood and level of motivation, too.

Does the sun leave you feeling alive or flustered? Does the cold leave you feeling jolly or down?

Before writing the name of a college on your list, research on the weather and see if it’s something that you can live with as you complete your program.

Keep in mind that most US states have four distinct seasons. This is why make sure that your college list is filled with schools that will let you be in your element no matter the weather condition.

student making list

What are Reach, Match and Safety Schools?

Reach schools are dream colleges whose admissions requirements are well above an applicant’s academic profile. On the other hand, match schools admit students whose academic profiles reflect that of the applicant. Safety schools are institutions where an applicant’s admissions chances are very high.

It’s not a wise move to fill your college list with prestigious schools since you’re always told to dream big. Likewise, it’s a no-no to sell yourself short by creating a college list with nothing but the most non-selective schools on the planet.

When building a college list, you should include schools that fall in the following three categories:

Reach schools

Also sometimes referred to as dream schools, reach schools are colleges and universities where your academic profile is below the average of their admissions requirements or the credentials of admitted students. Generally speaking, all prestigious schools in the US are reach schools for the majority of college-bound high schoolers.

Because the acceptance rates at reach schools are very low and your academic profile is not what they are looking for exactly, your chances of getting accepted into them is low. But anything is possible.

Each time you include a reach school on your college list, you are putting yourself at risk of being disappointed if you get a rejection letter.

However, you are also giving yourself a chance to earn a degree from an elite institution. This is why you should cut yourself some slack and include two to four reach schools on your college list.

Match schools

Some students call them target schools. Others refer to them as 50/50 schools. No matter what they are called, the fact remains that match schools are colleges and universities where your application matches the application of the majority of freshmen students admitted into them.

Needless to say, there is a good possibility that you will get a nod from their admissions officers. To increase your chances that at least one school on your college list will accept you, have two to four match schools.

Just because a thing or two on your academic profile falls below the average range for recent admits doesn’t mean that a college or university you wish to apply to should be considered a reach school. If most of your application meets the minimum requirements of the institution, it’s still a match school.

Safety schools

Also sometimes called back-up schools, safety schools, as the name suggests, are colleges and universities that will almost certainly welcome you into their campuses. That’s because your academic profile exceeds those of recently admitted freshmen students. However, always keep in mind that nothing in life (and admissions) is certain.

You can think of yourself as someone who is overqualified for a safety school, which means that your GPA, test score and class rank are higher than what the institution is looking for in applicants. Just remember to check out its acceptance rate. If the figure you see is below 80%, it’s not the best safety school to include on your college list.

Not too many students dream of attending their safety schools, but make sure that you will be happy to spend the next four years of your academic life there should it send you an acceptance letter.

Related Article: How Many Safety Schools Should You Apply To?

Having the right amount of reach, match and safety schools allows for a balanced college list.

college map

3 College List Examples

To help you find which schools to include in each category, you may estimate your chances of gaining admission with the help of a college chances calculator.

As the name pretty much suggests, a college chances calculator is a tool available online, usually cost-free, that you can use to facilitate your college list-building endeavor.

Different college chances calculators look and work differently. See to it that you opt for one that you can use trouble-free and has many positive feedback too.

To have a clear example of creating a solid college list, check out this table consisting of the academic profile and college preferences of three high school students in Massachusetts trying to figure out which institutions should be included on their respective college lists as reach, match and safety schools:

SAT EBRW score680720700
SAT Math score700740720
ACT score283430
Institution typePublic/PrivatePublic/PrivatePrivate
Tuition and fees$40,000$40,000$60,000
Programs/majorsComputer ScienceEngineeringPsychology
Campus settingAnyUrban/suburbanSuburban/town

Below, you will come across what a balanced college list would look like for Student A, Student B and Student C, based on their academic profiles and personal preferences given above:


Reach schools:

  • Boston College
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology
  • University of Rhode Island
  • University of Connecticut

Match schools:

  • Central Connecticut State University
  • College of Our Lady of the Elms
  • Fisher College
  • University of Bridgeport

Safety schools:

  • Bridgewater State University
  • Westfield State University


Reach schools:

Match schools:

Safety schools:

  • Alabama A&M University
  • California State University


Reach schools:

  • Claremont McKenna College
  • College of the Ozarks
  • Harvey Mudd College
  • Stanford University

Match schools:

  • Andrews University
  • Bucknell University
  • Lafayette College
  • Mississippi College

Safety schools:

  • Baker University
  • Oklahoma Wesleyan University

Just Before You Make a College List

It’s not enough that you fill your college list with schools that you like. It’s also a must that you include some institutions that will like your academic profile.

Above, we talked about creating not just any college list but a balanced and realistic college list that can help keep at bay unnecessary stress and disappointment.

See to it that yours consists of the right amount of reach, match and safety schools, and there’s a huge possibility that you will receive at least one acceptance letter in the mail.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of the College Reality Check.

Similar Posts